Plymouth Church Brooklyn, Henry Ward Beecher and the Civil War Photo Tour

Although I live on Long Island, I was often in historic Brooklyn to visit Michele. I will be sharing some picture that I took in 2015 of Civil War era sites and buildings in that most beautiful of boroughs.

The first comes from my visit there one Sunday to a church that figured prominently in the coming of the Civil War. Plymouth Church was a Congregational church founded by transplanted New Englanders. The church was built in 1849-1850.

plymouth church brooklyn.PNG

The first minister of Plymouth Church was Henry Ward Beecher. The beautiful churchyard contains a statue of him. Beecher was the son of Lyman Beecher, who helped stir up anti-Irish riots in Boston. His sister Harriet Beecher Stowe would write Uncle Tom’s Cabin.

plymouth church yard.PNG

The statue of Henry Ward Beecher was created by Gutzon Borglum, the sculptor who designed both Mount Rushmore and the Confederate memorial on Stone Mountain in Georgia. It is ironic that New York’s leading abolitionist was memorialized by the same artist who etched Jefferson Davis and Robert E. Lee into a mountainside.

The statue is controversial in the neighborhood because the black figures are shown at the base of it in a subordinate pose.

plymouth henry ward beecher.PNG

In February 1860, Abraham Lincoln gave one of the most important speeches of his life at Cooper Union. It established him as a major contended for the presidency. The day before, he worshiped at Plymouth Church, which was seen as a way of him identifying with the growing anti-slavery movement in New York. He also went to services at Plymouth three weeks later. This is the only New York church where Lincoln is known to have worshiped at.

There is a “Lincoln niche” in the churchyard memorializing those visits.

plymouth lincoln.PNG

This street outside of Plymouth Church in Brooklyn has seen a lot of things that belie its quiet appearance. During the 1850s the church was a stop on the Underground Railroad for escaping slaves and it was the scene of notorious “slave auctions” to raise money to buy freedom for slaves. People like Mark Twain, Clara Barton, Charles Dickens, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Horace Greeley, William Thackery, and Martin Luther King spoke here.

plymougth street scene.PNG

The Historic Brooklyn Heights area contains many Civil War Era buildings. Streetscenes today sometimes seem like they come from 150 years ago, as in this picture taken across from Plymouth Church.

plymouth street scene 2.PNG

Here is the church from the balcony. In Beecher’s day the church held 2,000 people for ordinary services. There were two services every Sunday. Up to a thousand additional folding seats could be set up for special occasions.

plymouth1.JPG

The lectern was made from olive tree wood brought back from a church trip to the Holy Land in 1867. The raised platform it is on is where Beecher preached and where he held his “slave auctions.”

plymouth 2.JPG

The church has a substantial balcony, and a smaller upper balcony at the very back of the church where the American flag hangs. Under the upper balcony are stained glass windows of Beecher, Lincoln, and women in education.

plymouth 3.JPG

Here is the view from the highest balcony.

plymouth 4.JPG

Here is the first of the three windows over the rear balcony. This is Beecher speaking in England in 1863. He was sent by Lincoln to speak in manufacturing cities to try to win workers and merchants over to the Union cause even though unemployment in these cities had spiked due to the blockade.

plymouth beecher window.JPG

Here is the third window. It represents Women in Education. The seated woman on the left is Beecher’s sister Harriet Beecher Stowe. She lived in Hartford, but she was a member of the church and worshiped there many times.

plymouth women.JPG
At the time of the Civil War, the windows were plain glass. The three dozen beautiful stained glass windows were installed over the decades after the war.

The side windows are essentially “Great Moments in Protestantism.” There are windows at both the ground level and above the first balcony.

plymouth windows.JPG

I will post shots of a few of the windows. The first is John Milton calling for religious freedom for Protestants and the second shows the Pilgrims landing in Plymouth.

plymouth john milton.JPG
plymouth pilgrims.JPG

Even though the church is in New York, it was founded by transplanted New Englanders, Congregationalists transplanted from Mass, RI, and Ct. A lot of the windows commemorate New England, not New York.

Here is a window showing the founding of Harvard. There is another showing the founding of Williams College.

plymouth harvard.JPG

So, you also see windows giving tribute to people like Jonathan Edwards, the leader of the Great Awakening, who were important New England religious figures.

plymouth jonathan edwards.JPG

Here is Lyman Beecher, father of Henry Ward Beecher and Harriet Beecher Stowe. Lyman set off the first large anti-Irish riots in Boston with his repeated anti-immigrant sermons.

plymouth lyman beecher.JPG

The church used organ music and had a hymnal that included black spirituals. This gigantic working organ dates to 1867.

plymouth organ.JPG
plymouth organ 2.JPG

Here is the platform where Beecher held his “slave auctions.” He “sold” escaped slaves to the congregation and used the proceeds to pay for their freedom.

plymouth platform.JPG

Here is the platform seen from the altar. The podium was made from olive tree wood brought back from a church pilgrimate to the Holy Land in 1867.

plymouth platform 2.JPG

The pews you see in the church today are the same ones there in Beecher’s day. Lincoln worshiped at the church twice in 1860. This is where he sat.

plymouth lincoln pew.JPG

My generous guide Lois sitting behind Lincoln’s seat.

plymouth lois.JPG

There are a number of memorials to Beecher around the church.

plymouth beecher mem.JPG

One of the slaves Beecher “sold” was this girl “Pinky:

plymouth pinky.JPG

There is an exhibit on the slaves who were auctioned,

pinky arcade.JPG

Here is Pinky’s Ring.

plymouth ring.JPG

Here is an explanation of the ring.

plymouth pinky ring.JPG

A painting of Pinky with her ring.

plymouth pinky painting.JPG

There are illustrations of the slave auctions in the historical gallery.

plymouth slave auction.JPG

In the 1920s, one former slave who had been freed through one of Beecher’s auctions returned to the church to speak:

plymouth Cathy.JPG

The church has several Puritan relics, like this piece of Plymouth Rock.

plymouth rock.JPG

Lewis Tappan, a national leader of the abolitionist movement, was a member of the church and lived just a few blocks away.

plymouth tappan.JPG

The exhibits are housed in a gallery called Pinky’s Arcade

plymouth pinkys arcade.JPG

It is believed that the undercroft of the church was used to hide runaway slave.

plymouth under.JPG

Painting of Beecher at the church.

plymouth beecher.JPG

Beecher and Wife. Beecher would fall from influence when his affair with a congregant was revealed.

plymouth wife.JPG

There is an interesting exhibit on the Beechers as commercial spokespeople. They were celebs and they profited by endorsing products like Mrs. Beecher’s Plasters.

plymouth ad.JPG

Beecher is shown in the upper right of this ad for pool tables. He encourages people “Play billiards at home” to avoid the evils of pool halls. The church had pool tables when he was pastor.

plymouth pool.JPG

In addition to the stained glass in the main church, the parish hall area has stained glass made by Louis Tiffany. These can only be seen on the tour. Here is one example.

plymouth tiffany.JPG

plymouth tiffany2.JPG

There is a display case devoted to the author of Uncle Tom’s Cabin, Harriet Beecher Stowe.

plymouth harriet 2.JPG

Here is a spinoff play from Uncle Tom.

plymouth harriet.JPG

Here is a map of the area around the church, which is located at 57 Orange St. in Historic Brooklyn Heights. As you can see, it is in the Fruit Streets section.

plymouth church 57 orange st.JPG
The area near the church is among the highest priced property in the United States. While the streets immediately surrounding the church are exclusively residential, there are a range of dining establishments within a few blocks walk. Delis can be a great place to grab a sandwich and walk west to views of the harbor, although work on the Promenade makes spots to sit more difficult to find. There are also mid-range places like Park Plaza diner at the corner of Cadman Plaza and Pineapple Walk.

Beecher’s grave at Greenwood Cemetery.

beecher.JPG
The church has a Landmark designation.
Here is the New York City interpretive panel.
All color photos taken by Pat Young.
To see more sites Pat visited CLICK HERE
Follow Reconstruction Blog on Social Media:

Author: Patrick Young

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *