November 14, 1865 was a day set aside by the State of Pennsylvania to honor the Black men who joined the United States Colored Troops and other Black units. There was a Grand Review (a parade of Colored soldiers and sailors through the capital city of Harrisburg), presentations to the heroes of the war, speeches by local notables, and a reception to honor the men who had risked their lives to free fellow African Americans from slavery in the South. While this celebration was large and was supported by many Pennsylvanians, it also grew out of disappointment.
In May of 1865, there had been an even bigger Grand Review for the entire army in Washington. Abraham Lincoln had died a month before, and new President Andrew Johnson presided over that gathering just a few short weeks after the last major Confederate forces had surrendered. That day tens of thousands of spectators lined up along Pennsylvania Avenue to welcome the victorious heroes home. And it would be outdone the next day when the armies of the west under Major General William T. Sherman would be honored.
School children had two days off so they could hail the saviors of their country. All through the city hung American flags. Banners were placed outside of buildings filled with loving greetings to the men who had been away from home for four years. Outside the Treasury Department hung a banner that proclaimed “THE ONLY NATIONAL DEBT WE CAN NEVER REPAY IS THE DEBT WE OWE OUR VICTORIOUS UNION SOLDIERS.”
The young soldiers would march two miles down Pennsylvania Avenue to the White House where President Johnson, his cabinet, Ulysses S. Grant, and William T. Sherman waited to give them honor. The Army of the Potomac, with Major General George Gordon Meade at its head, was the first army to march. The soldiers of the East were so large in number that it took six hours before they had marched past the president. The next day, the same amount of time was devoted to the soldiers of the west. But no time was devoted to the Black veterans of the war. The United States Colored Troops, of which there were 200,000 men, were not even invited. Even though Lincoln’s funeral ceremonies in April involved Black troops, by May, under a different president, Blacks were excluded. I should say, Black SOLDIERS were excluded.
The New York Times said that Colored people provided “comic relief” coming up behind as refugees and servants to the white units. The Times reporter wrote “It was a most nonchalant, grotesque spectacle—two very diminutive white donkeys bestrode by two diminutive black contrabands.” Black men and Black women had their place driving teams of mules or as cooks. When the African Americans appeared in their diminished roles, the Times said they “brought laughter and cheers from end to end of the avenue.” Blacks were seen as superfluous children, a laughing stock for the amusement of the white spectators. They were not even recognized as soldiers. The army, which had been virtually all white in 1861 when the war started, had returned to its whites-only fantasy four years later in its final ceremonies.
When Black Pennsylvanian mothers and wives heard of the slight to their husbands and sons who had served, they began meeting together to plan a welcome back for the United States Colored Troops (U.S.C.T.) who were being discharged months after the end of the war. Pennsylvania had played a big role in ending slavery. It was a hub of the Underground Railroad and the Abolitionist movement before the war. Its free Black population provided soldiers to the first Northern Black regiment, the 54th Massachusetts, from Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, but also from Harrisburg, Chambersburg, Lancaster, and a half-dozen other communities in the Keystone State. Many regiments of the United States Colored Troops were recruited there, and the largest training ground for the new recruits was at Camp William Penn north of Philadelphia.
The late summer of 1865 saw Harrisburg’s Black residents form the Garnet League, named in honor of the African American abolitionist and minister Henry Highland Garnet who was a chaplain to several United States Colored regiments. The Garnet League was a member of the Pennsylvania State Equal Rights League. It was established, according to its president, to “promote the interest of our people at home, to encourage mental improvement and moral rectitude, and to defend our race when assaulted in the person of any colored man and woman.” The Garnet League made honoring the Blacks who fought in the war its special project.
The Garnet League in its official publication on the Harrisburg ceremonies said that “We, therefore, as colored native born citizens, claim for ourselves all the rights, privileges and franchises enjoyed by our fellow-citizens of another race.” They were not just honoring the Black soldiers and sailors, they were remembering their own contribution as a community to saving the Union and ending slavery.
The Garnet League was helped by William Howard Day, a freeborn New Yorker who had risen to prominence before the war as an antislavery lecturer. In his Garnet League lecture in Harrisburg he told the audience that during the Civil War “when defeat came to humiliate the nation’s pride—when the disaster of the first Bull Run fell with crushing weight on the national ardor…Thereafter, on many well contested battle-fields, the African had fairly attested his valor and established his ability to fight. Having exhibited his ability, having established his power in assisting to preserve the Government, why should he not be invested with equal rights in participating in the control thereof?” He predicted that “Political equality might not be conceded to the negro of today, or tomorrow, or in a year hence—but equality before the law would come—must come—because God rules on earth as well as in heaven!”
The Garnet League reached out to other Black organizations to plan the reception for the soldiers and to Black newspapers to try to rally the community to come to Harrisburg for the Grand Review. While some Black Philadelphians said that their own city should be the place for such honors, this was rejected because Harrisburg was so central geographically and served by so many railroad lines it was the natural location for a statewide celebration. In addition, Confederate raids had threatened Harrisburg three times during the war, and the Confederate invasion in June of 1863 had brought the Rebel army to just across the Susquehanna River from the capital.
With November 14th set as the day of remembrance, the Harrisburg Black community decorated the streets with patriotic displays that also urged the white community to respond by lifting all race-based restrictions on the state’s African Americans. They also raised money to pay the fares for soldiers who had returned home so they could come and they had all the railroads transporting veterans to Harrisburg reduce their fares in half. While many whites in Harrisburg joined in to honor the veterans, the local Democratic newspaper, the Harrisburg Patriot, was critical of the ceremonies and white vandals attacked some outdoor decorations on the evening of November 13th.
The parade got off at 10 AM on November 14, 1865. A reporter from the Philadelphia Inquirer wrote that “No day could have been chosen more propitious for the occasion.” He said that the day was “one of the finest of this most pleasant Indian summer.”
The procession marched to the home of former Secretary of War Simon Cameron, who was very ill at the time. Cameron met the marchers and offered an apology there saying that “Your services, offered in the early part of the war, were refused; but when the struggle became one of life and death, then the country gladly received you, and thank God, you nobly redeemed all you promised.” Cameron, who had been the Governor of Pennsylvania, told them “I can only say again that I thank you from my heart for all that you have done for your country, and I know the country will hold you in grateful remembrance.” He promised them that “you will have all the rights you ask for, all the rights that belong to human beings” While some African Americans were disappointed with President Andrew Johnson’s approach to civil rights, Cameron told them “Remember, when the war began, there were 4,000,000 of slaves in this country, protected by law. Now all men are made free by the law. Thank God for all this! For He alone has accomplished the work!”
Next to Cameron on his porch were Bvt. Major General Kiddoo and Brig. Gen. John P. Brisbin. Kiddoo had served with a United States Colored Infantry regiment and he was particularly appreciated for serving beside Black troops with the danger of being executed by Confederates if captured. After the war, he became an assistant commissioner in the Freedmen’s Bureau in Texas. After the Review was over, Kiddoo presided over the mustering-out of the 640 men of the 22nd U.S.C.T.

The parade then proceeded to the Hills Capitol Building which was the seat of government from 1822 to 1897. Lincoln had visited the capitol while on his way to Washington in February 1861. He would lie in state there after he was assassinated just half-a-year before the Harrisburg U.S.C.T. Grand Review. After an invocation, letters were read from Major General George Meade of the Army of the Potomac, and Major General Benjamin Butler, the commander of the Army of the James.
One of the speakers told the audience that they could “Go to the White House, and scan the crowds of repentant Rebels, seeking for pardon. How many black faces can be counted among them? …Not one. In the annals of our civil war it will be recorded, to the honor of black Americans, that they proved invariably true to the mother land that had been false to them, and that denied to them at first an opportunity of taking part in a white man’s war.” [Ceremonies at the Reception of Welcome to the Colored Soldiers of Pennsylvania (1865) Samito p. 162]
The gathering also passed resolutions calling for the recognition of the role of Black soldiers and sailors and that distinctions of color should not compromise the rights of Black Pennsylvanians. One resolution said that: “Resolved, that while the United States are bound by the Federal Constitution to guarantee to every State in this Union a republican form of government: such a form of government truly interpreted by the lights afforded by the Declaration of Independence is utterly incompatible with distinctions based on race or color…” [Ceremonies at the Reception of Welcome to the Colored Soldiers of Pennsylvania (1865) Samito p. 163]
Sources:
Marching Home: Union Veterans and Their Unending Civil War by Brian Matthew Jordan published by Liveright Publishing Corp. (2015)
Follow Reconstruction Blog on Social Media: