Second Judge Issues Order Halting Construction of Triumphal Arch Next to Arlington National Cemetery

Today, U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema became the second Federal judge to issue an order blocking President Donald Trump’s proposed Triumphal Arch next to Arlington National Cemetery. During a hearing on the arch, Brinkema said “It seems like a rush job…I don’t see any way where the defense could be successful on the merits in this case…..You don’t have Congressional approval for this project.” The Justice Department had argued that a 1925 law authorizing the construction of the Memorial Bridge gave the president the authority to begin construction of the arch, which was not included in the original century-old legislation allowing the construction of the bridge. The judge told the Justice Department that “I think it really hurts your credibility with the courts by focusing on that…There was no arch provided for in that statute.” The judge was particularly critical of the plan going ahead without consideration of the safety of passengers landing and taking off at nearby Ronald Reagan Airport. The cranes constructing the arch would rise to more than three hundred feet. The 1925 statue “was written before National Airport even existed,” Brinkema said.

The judge was also concerned that during the construction, the traffic circle will be closed to vehicular traffic, including rescue vehicles responding to emergencies at Ronald Reagan Airport. “Once one of the major roadways is closed, it clogs up everything,” Brinkema said. She said that the Administration “has not analyzed the potential impacts.”

Brinkema issued an order stopping construction during the entire time the trial is taking place. She said that she did not see “any way” that the Administration will win in court.

This is the second order this week halting the construction, by two different judges.

The arch is proposed for Memorial Circle. The arch will, according to the National Park Service, impact nine Civil War-related sites in the District of Columbia and Virginia. The arch was proposed as a commemorative monument to Donald Trump or to the 250th birthday of the Declaration of Independence, depending on the story being told by White House spokespersons, but over the summer the administration said that the arch was being built as a national security structure.

Note: The feature photograph is taken from the official site for the arch.

Follow Reconstruction Blog on Social Media:

Author: Patrick Young