Requiem for Reconstruction: Black Countermemory and the Legacy of the Lowcountry’s Lost Political Generation
by Robert D. Bland published by University of North Carolina Press 260 pages (2025)
One of the best places to study Reconstruction is one of the first places where Reconstruction came on. The South Carolina Lowcountry, where the state hits the sea, including the Sea Islands and their continental adjoining counties, had one of the longest histories of Reconstruction.
The Sea Islands were conquered by the United States in 1862. Northern strategists looked on these islands as a place to cutoff blockade-running by the Confederacy and to secure a base for an offensive against Charleston. Unlike other areas of the South where Black and White populations were roughly equivalent, the Sea Islands permanent resident population was overwhelmingly Black. Because it was so isolated from the Anglo communities, the enslaved population developed their own Gullah–Geechee culture and their own English-based creole language. When the United States Navy and Army sailed into places like Beaufort and Port Royal they were confronted with a people they were not even aware of before the war. Because these liberated islands stood like a light to the Black populations of North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia, they were growing in population every month after the slave owners fled.
The United States had not even considered what to do with the Black population before they conquered the Sea Islands. Fortunately Gullah–Geechee had strong leaders who could propose a way forward. After military bases were set up, the freedpeople supported the arrival of abolitionist teachers and missionaries from the North who would educate the population and create strong ties with white Northerners hopeful about the Port Royal “Experiment.”
Just a few months after the liberation, the islands generated the first nationally-known hero of the Gullah-Geechee. Robert Smalls was functioning as a pilot on the small Confederate ship the C.S.C. Planter based on Charleston. In May, Smalls escaped slavery and came into the Union lines on the Planter. He was instantly praised in the Republican newspapers throughout the North.

Smalls became a leader among the refugees from slavery along the Carolina Coast. After the war, he was a delegate to the South Carolina Constitutional Convention where he strongly advocated free public education for all children regardless of race. He was then elected to the South Carolina legislature, the first African American to serve. In 1874 he was elected to the United States House of Representatives. Smalls had great talent as a public servant, but he had come to prominence through the Black “counter-memory” of the Civil War. At the same time that Northern Sectional Reconciliation and Southern Lost Cause worldviews dominated white memory of the war and Reconstruction, The Black counter-memory challenged the white Weltanschauung, which had little place for African Americans, and the counter-memory led Blacks to create and recognize their own identity separate from the narrow confines that the white world recognized.
Professor Robert Bland explains that:
“The South Carolina Lowcountry served as the primary site for the Reconstruction generation’s countermemory. A prominent and well-trod site in Civil War–era scholarship, the Lowcountry has long been understood to be at the center of wartime Reconstruction and the long struggle to make postemancipation Black freedom meaningful. One of the first places in the South where the planter class was expelled during the war, the Lowcountry became a hub for experiments in establishing free labor ideology, saw some of the first efforts to organize regiments of the formerly enslaved into the US military, was used as a platform where the Union army broadcast the official enactment of the Emancipation Proclamation, and experimented with some of the most radical efforts in wartime land redistribution. The Lowcountry was also home to one of the first national cemeteries in the Deep South and a cornerstone in Union memory of the war—highlighting the highest-frequency promise of emancipation.”
Bland looks at the way the memory of the Civil War was kept alive in Lowcountry after Reconstruction ended. Confederate veterans were taking over the public spaces in South Carolina. Through a stolen election, former Confederate General Wade Hampton had become governor on the backs of the state’s Redshirted terrorists. Confederate Memorial Day was a common commemoration among white people. Posts of the United Confederate Veterans were spring up in every large village in the state. History books were rewritten to honor the Confederacy and Confederate monuments were put up at all important crossroads. Tourism in the late 19th Century meant that whites could come to Charleston to tour Fort Sumter, one of the most revered sites of Confederate victory. Bland says that Lowcountry Blacks fought back; “More than a mausoleum for a broad and undifferentiated Northern unionism, the Lowcountry’s commemorative landscape remained a living mecca for Black countermemory well into the twentieth century.” Black historical memory was not just keeping alive old times, it helped to set an agenda for Black identity in the future where African Americans could struggle for the same rights they had had between 1865 and 1876.
White Southerners made the Lowcountry a primary focus of their ideological attacks as they worked to reestablish white supremacy throughout the old Confederate states. The Lowcountry was a place of corruption and crime, with incompetent Blacks running the government, the culture, and the economy according to the white supremacists. To counter this distorted memory, Black newspapers created the Southern government reporting beat which investigated how many government agencies were administered during Reconstruction and its immediate aftermath. The articles they published gave African Americans a less distorted view of their own community’s ability to help govern the South. Bland says that African American elected officials were avatars for the “race” that could be held up and copied in other parts of the region.
The newspapers also covered the racist violence unleashed by the Klan, the White League, and dozens of other white supremacist groups. Even in the 1870s, Black readers were reminded that whipping and lynchings were common under slavery, and mass executions of United States Colored Troops were ubiquitous during the Civil War. Black newspapers used the earlier experience of violent repression to make the new forms of political turbulence as a continuation of decades-old political repression.
These developments in recording Reconstruction by Blacks led to a new kind of history. While the “Dunning School” histories dictated how whites were deceived into siding with the Ku Klux Klan and other terrorist organization, Black writers used Black newspapers and Black primary sources to offer a more realistic approach to the history of the 1860s, 1870s, and 1880s. Many modern people wonder why Americans accepted the distortions of the Dunning School without question, but they do not realize that Black historical memory for the last 150 years never did bow down to the Dunning School.
Bland explains this new power that Black writers had:
“When we pay attention to how the Reconstruction generation grappled with postbellum political history, new dimensions of the modern Black public sphere begin to appear. While many members of the Reconstruction generation possessed a deep familiarity with the antebellum world of colored conventions, Black church networks, and the Black press, Reconstruction radically altered the scale and scope of the nation’s imagined Black public. A largely Northern project before the Civil War, the new networks of communication between South and North during Reconstruction helped to dramatically expand the circulation and vision of the Black public sphere. The exponential increase in the number of schools and colleges in the South greatly expanded the base of readers for the Black press. In addition, emancipation and Reconstruction transformed the South into a new theater for journalistic coverage and consumption, first for accounts of the Black teachers and missionaries taking part in wartime Reconstruction, and later in the coverage of the wave of officeholders who embodied the highest promise of the postbellum racial destiny.”
These Black writers were not just preserving the actions of their community during Reconstruction, they were also preserving the dreams of African Americans for the future.
The book also examines the ways that the people of the Lowcountry kept the memory of Reconstruction alive in the face violent attempts to suppress that memory. The Red Shirts sought the reimposition not just political white supremacy but also sewing the white reactionary memory of the decades after the Civil War. The story of how Black people resisted the white imposition of the Dunning School became incorporated in their story.
Bland uses Robert Smalls as a particularly emblematic figure in freeing, organizing, and representing the people of the Lowcountry. Of course, Smalls was also a politician, which his detractors, both white and Black, was a source of constant criticism. Of course, many of the critics were also politicians. When Smalls was elected to Congress, he won the election because he had proven so true in the face of death, and in his new national position he made sure that the president and his fellow Congressmen understood what his constituents faced in his home district. Bland characterized Smalls as the last Reconstruction Congressman, When he left Congress, national awareness of the memory of Black Reconstruction began to fade.
Requiem for Reconstruction applies memory studies, now so common in works on the Civil War, to the construction of a usable past history of Reconstruction. Of course it does not give us conclusory evidence about the African American American memory throughout the entire United States or the South. It only concerns one region in South Carolina. However, the methodology used to study the Lowcountry can be applied to other regions in the old Confederacy. If more historians follow Professor Bland’s example perhaps one day a consensus work on the memory of Reconstruction could be out together.
Follow Reconstruction Blog on Social Media: